Thank you for sharing this page.


EUA publishes first findings from DEFINE project on 'funding efficiency' measures

17 December 2013

As part of the “Designing strategies for efficient funding of higher education in Europe (DEFINE)” project, the European University Association (EUA) has been collecting information and data from national rectors’ conferences/university associations on the different public funding modalities and efficiency measures (including performance-based funding, concentration measures and excellence schemes) in place in Europe and their impact on universities.

The preliminary results of this analysis, which are based on input from 24 European countries, have now been published in an interim report. Some of the main observations highlighted in the report are:

  • How public funding is delivered to universities: While this varies greatly between countries, the vast majority of higher education systems now use some type of performance-based elements in their funding. These include funding formulae (based on a series of indicators) and/or so-called performance contracts. For example, over 50% of the universities’ overall public funding comes from formula-based block grants in at least eight European HE systems. The report looks at the relative importance of the different indicators used, considering input indicators such as numbers of students, and those focusing on outputs such as the number of graduates. Teaching and research activities are often funded differently. While input indicators such as the numbers of Bachelor and Master students are the most important criteria for funding teaching activities, research activities tend to be funded mainly on the basis of output indicators such as doctoral degrees or the amount of external funding (see figure 2 of report). Meanwhile, performance contracts, whereby certain goals are agreed between public authorities and universities, are a common feature found in 15 of the HE systems considered in the study.
  • How the higher education landscape is being restructured: In almost all countries studied, authorities and universities are either considering or taking steps towards merger processes, with a view – along with other objectives – to rationalise funding allocation. The nature of these merger processes varies across Europe, with the deepest restructuring taking place in Denmark, Estonia, Finland or Latvia. However, mergers are only one of the many different concentration and collaboration phenomena occurring in higher education. Examples include the creation of university consortia and strategic partnerships. Public authorities encourage these processes via setting up specific funding schemes, often with a focus on excellence. Large-scale initiatives such as in Germany and France, where additional funding has been made available to universities, remain an exception but have an important impact on the system as a whole.
  • How universities seek to optimise the use of resources: Universities are actively seeking to improve efficiency both internally and by creating synergies within the sector, but regulatory frameworks strongly determine the capacity to implement different measures.

The interim report concludes with a series of key messages which have been drawn from the project consultations, analysis, and discussions at a recent seminar on the topic which brought together university representatives from across Europe. The messages highlight that universities have an important role to play in the funding efficiency area, and should be proactive in addressing this challenge to contribute to shaping this agenda. EUA will now take this work forward with three focus groups in the spring of 2014 that will gather small groups of HE experts from across Europe to analyse the institutional impact of the three groups of efficiency measures (performance-based funding; excellence schemes; and concentration measures) in more detail.

The interim report of the “Designing strategies for efficient funding of Higher Education in Europe” project, which is co-funded by the European Commission, can be downloaded from the EUA website.

DEFINE is a two-and-a-half year project (autumn 2012-spring 2015) run by EUA in collaboration with CIPES, the Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (Portugal), and the Universities of Oxford (UK), Aalto (Finland) and Erlangen-Nuremberg (Germany), and the Copenhagen Business School (Denmark). The project is co-funded by the European Commission under the Lifelong Learning Programme.

European University Association (EUA)

Brussels office:
Avenue de l’Yser, 24
1040 Brussels
Tel: +32 (0) 2 230 55 44

Geneva office:
114, Rue du Rhône
Case postale 3174
1211 Geneva 3
Tel: +41 22 552 02 96